Faux may be the most provocative restaurant I’ve been to in recent memory.
Not because the food is wildly inventive — the menu is straight-up bistro, with glances toward the South of France — nor because of any notable flourishes in décor, service or overall experience. If anything, it’s Faux’s very ordinariness that has made me question what exactly we want from restaurants. Even: What are restaurants for?
Faux, which opened in TriBeCa in early September, is a first effort from the 23-year-old George McNally. It sits just a few blocks from the Odeon, the cafeteria turned art-world nucleus that his father, Keith McNally, opened 46 years ago with Brian McNally and Lynn Wagenknecht, when TriBeCa by night was just a barrens of unlit warehouses.
Keith went on to make downtown downtown, staking a claim to SoHo in 1997 with the instantly, vaporizingly white-hot Balthazar (still besieged to this day), and bringing life to the dying meatpacking district in 1999 with the cunningly weathered simulacrum Pastis. But in Faux, he has played no role beyond beaming father. (On Instagram, he noted, half in complaint, half in pride, that his son had asked for neither advice nor money.)
Still, his ghost hovers. George, who grew up mostly in England, abandoned school at age 16 like his father, and found work at a pub, washing dishes and pulling pints. When he popped over to New York for a visit, his father drafted him as a bartender at Balthazar, where he showed a flair for martinis. For Faux, he salvaged tables, stained and scarred, from his father’s storehouses, and hired the designer Ian McPheely, who gave Balthazar its luster.
If you knew none of this stepping into Faux, you would never guess the connection.
Instead of jostling sprawl, you get intimate shadows, under a ceiling higher than the space is wide. The backdrop is Venetian plaster, whose color falls somewhere between coral and Margot Robbie’s skin room in the latest “Wuthering Heights.” Tawny booths, snugly curved, flaunt a punk-ish nailhead trim. Hand-painted tiles at head level reveal a spread of tarot cards: an angel pouring wine between goblets (balance), a hermit pointing his lantern toward the night (wisdom).
Someone clearly cared about the details, but wisely didn’t over-fuss, so the room feels lived in rather than orchestrated. If only the same breezy verve manifested on the plate.
I always enter a restaurant with hope. Over the course of my meals here, I kept hoping.
Panisse, chickpea fritters that traditionally hide creamy hearts inside golden crunch, were curiously mono-textured, pliant all the way through. The puff pastry base of a pissaladière seemed never to have achieved puff. Frites looked crisp but proved droopy inside, the Bartlebys of potatoes, exhausted by existence.
A Caesar salad was shaggy and bountiful, but I couldn’t taste the anchovies in the dressing, and the ones offered for a $6 surcharge arrived on a separate plate, three limp silver rags.
Most mysterious was the ratatouille, deconstructed to no discernible purpose, with slabs of zucchini, squash and eggplant laid over a mere gesture of stew — a crush of tomatoes emptied of all memory of the sun and earth that once fed them. Those tomatoes, or their glum cousins, recurred later as the dominant note in a confusingly un-marine bouillabaisse under mussels.
The “spicy” spaghetti wasn’t.
I eventually figured out how to cobble together a meal: warm olives bathed in rosemary-tinged olive oil, with a quickening of Calabrian chiles; grilled oysters daubed with bacon jam and garlic butter chunky with panko; an endive salad (at last, crunch); a respectable half-chicken. But octopus, smoky and succulent one night, was unnervingly salty another, and a rousing paccheri with sausage went gloppy in the second round.
For steak frites, the choice is entrecôte or the humbler Denver steak, a chuck cut introduced to the market in 2009, coming from a less used (thus less tough) muscle beneath the shoulder blade. Both were nicely chewy, although here, medium-rare appears to be a moving target.
The chef, Kristina Ramos, was born in Queens, lived in Provence and cooked at Eleven Madison Park. When she goes bold, the results can be inspiring, as with an au poivre that tasted ardently, almost pugnaciously, of pepper. The burger has solid credentials — a 30-day dry-aged blend of short rib and brisket from the butcher Pat LaFrieda — but what gives it intrigue is the sly sauce algérienne, of caramelized onions, garlic, tomatoes, bell peppers and mayo, ubiquitous in Europe as an anointment for kebabs and French tacos.
There is no pastry chef, which may explain the structural flaws in the mille-feuille (phyllo layers too hard to cut, so all the lemon curd squished out) and madeleines, leaden under a numbingly sweet lavender glaze.
It’s impossible not to recall Balthazar’s profiteroles, plural, when confronted here with one, singular, oversized but still lonely. A server pours the chocolate sauce tableside, then kindly leaves the pitcher, half full. The choux may have lost airiness at this larger scale, but let that go: The chocolate, dark and fortified by caramel, could redeem almost anything.
In its most basic definition, a restaurant is simply a place where you may buy and eat a meal. But at Faux, as the novelist Jay McInerney once wrote of the Odeon, eating is “almost beside the point.” The dining room is steadily packed with people in search of something more — scene, vibe, some fragile shimmer.
Do they find it? The restaurant has no sign. A doorman is stationed on the sidewalk to welcome you, but maybe also as a reminder that it’s a privilege to get in.
Inside, it’s batteringly loud, voices blurring and music at that fuzzy edge where the bass is pushed so high, every song sounds the same. On my first two visits, service was so dreamy and hands-off, I was startled, on the third, to be actively spoken to. If there was a vibe, it was benign tolerance.
Like the profiterole, I felt a little lonely.
















