Try to walk into Straker’s, a month-old 60-person restaurant in downtown Manhattan, and you’ll immediately be greeted by an a tall, imposing man. On a recent Monday evening, the man, whose employers would identify only as Ant, was leaning against the front of the restaurant dressed in a black leather jacket with silver spikes.
He asks would-be diners who approach the entrance, “Reservations?” If the answer is yes, he opens the heavy door and pulls back the velvet curtains. If it is a no, you are denied entry, even to speak to a host. “You can make a reservation online,” he explained on a recent evening. (Good luck with that — the current wait list is thousands of people long, according to some reports.)
In the last two years, bouncers like Ant have become a fixture at a certain kind of restaurant in New York City and other culinary capitals. The job description differs by establishment, from checking dress codes and reservations to keeping TikTokers away.
“At our places we call them security guards or just door managers,” said Noah Tepperberg, co-chief executive of Tao Group Hospitality, which owns eight restaurants in New York City. “We look at it as an amenity, an investment in the guest experience.” At Crane Club, a luxe restaurant in Chelsea with crimson banquettes and white tablecloths, the door managers walk guests to the car with an umbrella in the rain.
It’s an approach that is dividing diners, especially when doormen are working for quiet establishments on peaceful side streets and not large, boisterous clubstaurants. Some see these sentinels as gratuitous or pretentious, while others say they make them feel safe and chosen.
“Call me old school, but I think restaurants should want me there, and this doesn’t feel very hospitable,” said Patti Beranek, a 43-year-old musician who lives in Brooklyn. “It’s like the mean kids at school deciding what you can and can’t do.”
“I think there is a pretentiousness to it that people actually enjoy,” said Ella Nobay, 31, director of Business Development and Strategic Partnerships at of United Talent Agency who lives in London. “It gives a sense of exclusivity, like you achieved something by getting in the door.” She recently got past a doorman at the Horses, a new upscale pub and restaurant in Clerkenwell, a neighborhood in central London.
These gatekeepers are often found at restaurants that already have long wait lists, and tables that can often be secured only through connections. They block another, more old-fashioned way of getting a seat: simply walking in.
“It’s funny, because there is now a multilayered way of getting in,” said Gary Kaminsky, 63, a retired finance executive who lives in Manhattan and frequents many restaurants with a bouncer, including the Corner Store and Or’esh, all trendy restaurants owned by Catch Hospitality Group. “First you have to get a reservation, which might entail having a relationship with the maître d’ and host, but then you also have to have the relationship with the people at the door.”
Mr. Tepperberg believes that something is lost when you can’t walk into a restaurant, which is allowed at Tao restaurants with security. “I love being able to walk up and speak to the hostess,” he said. “You never know, maybe they have a cancellation?”
But he also understands why many restaurants don’t allow that, especially those with tight spaces. “If you have unwanted walk-ins you can’t operate and deliver good service sometimes,” he said. “Operationally you have to have someone out there whose job it is to traffic control.”
Thomas Straker, the founder and chef of Straker’s, said his bouncer provides a “slick guest experience.” He also expressed concerns about people jamming the small restaurant, and said his bouncer serves another important function: “This door is an old door that’s probably been there for 40 years, so we’ve got to make sure it’s shut behind them to stop the draft coming in and ruining the experience for guests who are sat at the bar.”
In the spring, Marine Giron-Galy, a partner and chief brand officer of AVA Coconut Grove, a Mediterranean restaurant that opened last year in Miami, along with her partners, decided to get rid of the restaurant’s security. “We realized we didn’t have the same late-night clubbing and foot traffic that our other restaurants had, and we were in a more family-oriented neighborhood,” she said. “We wanted those families to feel that they can come in freely.”
“This neighborhood had a sense of community, and we didn’t want to ruin that.” she said.
George McNally, the owner of Faux, a 50-seat French brasserie in SoHo that opened in September, is determined to have it both ways. He wants to have a doorman — “I think people in New York City like to feel like they are celebrities or amongst people like celebrities,” he said — but he wants everyone to feel welcome.
He employed Avery Jackson, a particularly friendly employee who stands outside every night from 4 p.m. and is instructed to let anyone on the street in for at least a drink at the bar.
“I hired someone who doesn’t have an ego,” Mr. McNally said. “I think it’s easy for people in that position to feel some kind of power.”
Mr. Jackson worked for nightclubs like Hotel Chantelle and Lost in Paradise for 20 years, and is struck by how different his new gig is. “You get to meet better people, and they are more sober when they come in,” he said. “Once in a while we have someone who had a few too many drinks who needs to be asked to leave, but that’s mostly the extent of the security problems.”
More frequently his job involves helping diners find the front door of the restaurant and avoid a tricky front step on the way out.
“We don’t have a sign, so I took it upon myself to ask people if they are walking down the street if they are looking for Faux,” he said. “I am now kind of the logo for the restaurant.”
















