The ideal way to watch “The Luckiest Man in America,” a dramatization of a real-life game show incident, is to go in cold — to see these events unfold as TV viewers did. If you’ve never heard of Michael Larson, a contestant who appeared on CBS’s “Press Your Luck” in 1984, then it is best to save YouTube for later.
In the movie’s version of events, Michael (Paul Walter Hauser) earns his spot on the program by crashing an audition, claiming to be someone he’s not. Bill Carruthers (David Strathairn), one of the show’s creators, nevertheless sees star potential in his Everyman persona.
Is Michael a loose cannon? The screenplay, by Maggie Briggs and the film’s director, Samir Oliveros, paints him as, at minimum, maladroit. He wears shorts with his tie and jacket. A woolly hairdo and beard look more freakish on Hauser than the real Michael’s did on him. The character also seems fine with bending the show’s rules, like the one that forbids phone calls during breaks.
Then Michael starts winning tens of thousands of dollars. And he keeps taking turns, even though each time he stands to lose it all. From here, the movie shifts into procedural mode, as the team in the control booth tries to sort out whether Michael is crazy or crafty. Shamier Anderson plays an employee who sleuths out Michael’s background during the taping. Oliveros is more selective in providing access to the protagonist’s thoughts.
The events, and the mind games, appear to have been goosed for dramatic interest. (One preposterous, surely invented interlude finds Michael wandering onto a talk show set and baring his soul to the host, played by Johnny Knoxville.) But it is still fun to watch Michael and CBS compete for the upper hand.
The Luckiest Man in America
Rated R. Language unfit for daytime TV. Running time: 1 hour 30 minutes. In theaters.
